Sent: Friday, November 21, 2003 5:33 AM
Subject: [againstslaughter] Supporting Sen Bill 1921,
January 2004
Dear Rep. Mathias,
Thank you for taking a moment to
read this email in support of SB1921. I am writing to ask if you would please
consider becoming a cosponsor of this excellent bill when it returns to the
house in January 2004.
Here are some key issues
regarding this bill, and rebuttals to some of the misinformation I have heard
spread regarding this bill. I would GREATLY appreciate it if you or a member
of your staff would take just a moment to let me know if you would please
cosponsor this bill.
- CAVEL
falsified documents to obtain their license. We do not need this type of
business in our fine state.
- These
foreign companies pay NO TARIFF on American horsemeat.
- If
they want to eat American meat, let it be our beef, our veal, our pork,
our chicken – meats grown, medicated, and cared for properly and safely
under the USDA.
- Their
countries have put bans on our beef, our meat exports that DO have
tariffs, claiming health concerns. Yet they continue to import our horses,
which are NOT regulated, not raised for food, not treated and cared for as
food animals. And, interestingly enough, NOT TARIFFED.
- Horses
are not raised like pigs/cattle/chickens, with meat production being the
intended end result. Horses
are fed known carinogens such as Bute every day without consideration that
the meat might later be consumed by humans, as more than 90% of
America’s horse owners have no idea horses are even slaughtered live in
this country.
- Legally,
horses are classified as companion animals. We do not slaughter dogs and
cats in this country to feed countries who consume these animals. Neither
should we slaughter our horses for them.
- Horse
theft dropped more than 30% in California, and stayed down, after
slaughter became illegal in that state.
- The
cost of disposal of a dying horse in central Illinois is no more than $100
via the University, and the animal’s death has educational and training
value for future veterinarians. Other parts of the state are in the
$100-150 range. This is a reasonable expense thousands of American horse
owners currently incur if they do not bury their animal on their property.
A very small portion of America’s horses are currently slaughtered to
death, and so the question of where the rest of the bodies would go is an
unrealistic question.
- Horses
and horse equipment are currently taxed as non-livestock, non-food,
pleasure items. If Illinois converts horses to livestock and slaughters
them as livestock, from their current legal status as COMPANIONS, then
these taxes must be revoked and income lost. Complex laws must be put in
place to properly regulate the treatment of these animals before they
become meat. Did you know Europe actually requires a passport for each
horse, including its full medical history and proof of ownership?
Do we really want/need to put this type of complexity into our
PLEASURE HORSE ownership when America does NOT eat horsemeat, does not
raise horses for meat, and DOES NOT GAIN ANY PROFIT VIA TARIFFS ON
HORSEMEAT?
- America
does not eat horsemeat. If these cultures wish to eat their own horses,
that is certainly their option. But in our culture, in our society, we do
not eat companion animals such as dogs, cats, and HORSES (please see 510
ILCS 70/2.01a, where horses are defined specifically as COMPANIONS).
- Please
allow me to state one last time, this bill has NOTHING to do with
livestock. Horses are NOT livestock. To say passing this bill will affect
livestock farming would be like saying to NOT pass this bill will mean
that Illinois will now start having slaughterhouses to slaughter other
companion animals – cats and dogs – for human consumption.
Sincerely,
Mrs.
AnnMarie Cross
Crosswinds Equine Rescue, Inc
a non-profit, 501c3 pending corporation
1476 NCR 1350 E Tuscola IL 61953
217-832-2010